aldi earls wet dog food review 2020
Earls Meaty Selection Trays Review
| Advertisement |
Suitable for all breeds of dogs
Private label(or
white label) pet foods are pre-formulated recipes that companies can order from certain factories, add their own label or packaging and retail to the public as their own brand. They are therefore available from numerous suppliers.
Click here for more info.
Mixing bowl composition
This is the ingredients list as printed on the packaging or manufacturer's website.
Think of the 'mixing bowl' composition like a recipe - all the ingredients you would need to put in a 'mixing bowl' in order to make the food.
Ingredients have to be listed in descending order of their weight so the higher it appears, the more there is.
Highlighted ingredients
Ingredients that we believe to be controversial or inferior are highlighted in yellow with particularly low grade, highly contentious or excessively vague ingredients in red.
As fed composition
While the 'mixing bowl' composition is useful for knowing what went into the food, it doesn't always reflect what your dog is actually eating. This is because the processes that turn the ingredients into the finished pet food can significantly alter the relative weights of the ingredients.
For this reason we've calculated the approximate 'as fed' percentages for the main ingredient categories in the finished product.
Please note that these figures are very approximate. They are estimates based on the information provided by the manufacturer in the ingredients list so the clearer the terminology and the more percentages they provide, the more accurate our estimates will be. Wherever information is lacking, we always assume the worst.
Ingredient categories
Meat ingredients: includes all meat and fish ingredients except isolated fats/oils.
Added oils and fats: includes all isolated oil and fat ingredients.
Carb-rich ingredients: includes all ingredients derived from grains, pseudo-grains, potatoes and other starchy root vegetables, sweet potato and legumes (except whole peas which are categorised under fruit and veg) except for isolated protein and extracted oils. Also includes fibre supplements.
Fruit and veg: includes all whole vegetables and fruits.
Other: all other ingredients. Mostly made up by nutritional supplements and additives.
For more information on any ingredient, please take a look at our Dog Food Ingredient Glossary
The dry matter level of a nutrient is the percentage there would be in the food if all of the water was removed.
With water taken out of the equation, these figures allow the nutrient levels of foods of different types (like wet and dry) to be compared on an even playing field.
Click here for more information
The
price per dayof feeding this food based on feeding the manufacturer's recommended daily amount from 1.8kg boxes bought at their rrp to a dog of:
Note:All suggested feeding amounts and costs are only approximate and may vary considerably from dog to dog. Be sure to contact the manufacturer if in any doubt.
51 out of 100-Average
Our unique product ratings are calculated based on a number of characteristics including the quality and quantity of the stated ingredients, certain nutritional and technological additives and the processing methods used to create the food. They are designed to indicate how beneficial we think a food is likely to be for the majority of dogs when fed on a daily basis for an extended period. Click here for more information
Country of origin: United Kingdom
A technological additive is any substance added to a pet food "for a technological purpose and which favourably affects the characteristics of feed".
The most common categories of technological additives include preservatives and antioxidants, gelling agents and thickeners and probiotics.
While the primary effects of technoloical additives are certainly 'favourable' (increased shelf life in the case of preservatives & antioxidants, better food texture and consistency in the case of gelling agents and thickeners etc.) some have been linked to health problems in pets and should be treated with caution.
Unfortunately, many technological additives do not have to be declared by the manufacturer so just because they do not appear on the label does not necessarily mean they are not in the food. If in doubt, ask the manufacturer directly exactly what technological additives their foods contain.
The Aldi Dog Food Review: Tested & Evaluated 2024
The Aldi Dog Food Review: Tested & Evaluated 2024
Written By Eloisa Thomas| Canine Coach, Double M.A in Anthropology.Edited & Fact Checked ByRenae Soppe| B.A Journalism & Science.Last Updated: 7th January 2024
Wondering about this supermarket brand? Is this the best option for your pup? Well, wonder no more!
We teamed up with a panel of independent experts and have created the ultimate Aldi dog food review. After several months of research and debate and dozens of Aldi dog foods tested, we were able to agree on this list of the retailer's best choices. That way, you can make an informed decision. Heres what you should know!
- Aldi has two dog food brands: Aldi Julius Dog Food and Natural Elements Dog food
- Natural Elements dog food is their grain-free line and has a better composition than Julius dog food
- This brand only offers adult dog kibble and one wet food recipe
Quick Pick - Our Best Rated Dog Food
Our Number 1 Pick -Petzyo Dog Food
- Ethically sourced kangaroo, chicken or salmon, sweet potato & superfood extras
- Iron-rich & low fat proteins
- Three Omega-3 and Omega-6 rich oils with a well balanced 11% fat content
- Made in Australia
Australia's Aldi Dog Food (Natural Elements) Review
Aldi Dog food - 3 Star Rating
- Ingredients: Aldi natural elements Chicken recipe: Poultry Meal (Source of Chicken), Peas, Poultry Tallow (Contains Rosemary Extract, Antioxidants), Tapioca, Potato, Sweet Potato, Gravy, Vitamins & Minerals, Beet Pulp, Salmon Oil, Vegetable Oil, Chicory Root, Yucca Schidigera Extract, Coconut Oil, Alfalfa, Blueberries, Cranberries, Pumpkin, Parsley Flakes, Chondroitin Sulphate, Glucosamine, Rosemary, Taurine, Kelp Meal, Beta Carotene
- Named Protein First:No, but meal is OK.
- Dog Food Type: Dry and wet food
- Recipe Range: Chicken and salmon kibble recipes, one wet food, and treats in both chicken and beef flavours.
- Suitable For: Adult dogs (can be fed to puppies and seniors)
- Cost: $$
- Australian Owned: No, but it is made in Australia
Before getting into our Aldi supermarket dog food review, its important to mention this supermarket has had different dog food home brands. Up until early 2020, Aldi sold their Julius dog food in the Australian market.
Since then, their Natural Elements dog food brand was born. As of the writing of this article, Natural Elements is the most easily available of the two. Because of this, the following dog food review will focus on Aldi Natural Elements dog food.
Interested in a Julius Dog food review? Our independent team also covered those recipes down below!
Aldi Natural Elements Dog Food Review
Aldi Natural Elements Dog Food Review |
|---|
Taste 5/5
This food seems to be tasty enough for dogs to enjoy it. Some members of our research team reported that their pups had a hard time getting used to it, but after a couple of days, they took to the new brand with gusto. This is very normal whenever youre swapping foods, which is why we recommend slowly fazing out the previous kibble and increasing the new food progressively.
PRO TIP:Got a new dog food brand for your dog? Dont just give a bowl of the new one! To avoid digestive trouble, you need to slowly introduce the new food and lower the percentage of old food. Most dog food brands have a portion guide on the packaging: use it!
Considering the taste of this brand doesnt seem overly remarkable, our panel is giving Aldi Natural Elements 5 out of 5 in this category.
Ingredients 3/5
Aldis kibble has a decent ingredient list. This dog food has a guaranteed analysis with a minimum of 28% crude protein, and 18% of fat. I like the overall percentage of protein since its above the 18% recommended by the AAFCO [1]. Well examine the quality of the protein in the next category.
All kibble recipes are grain-free as well as their wet food. However, our team noticed that treats arent marketed as grain-free so be careful if youre looking to avoid cereals in your dogs diet.
The first item is poultry meal, followed by peas and poultry tallow. Considering the respectable 18% crude fat content, this shows that poultry meals and peas are the bulk of the food, with percentages that probably are around the 50/50 mark. This is good news! Poultry meal is a nice protein source, and peas can be healthy for dogs.
Related:Real Meat vs Meat Meal in Dog Food.
Our independent experts think that it's important to note, however, that a high legume consumption (including peas) have been recently linked to a higher chance of heart disease [2]. A study by UC Davis lab showed that high legume consumption and grain-free diets can cause dangerous taurine deficiency, which is an essential nutrient for heart health [3]. To help lower the risk, its important to make sure your dog gets enough taurine from their diet through homemade toppings and raw dog food.
PRO TIP:Taurine is a heat-sensitive amino acid, so cooked dog food like kibble tends to have a lower content. To bump up your dogs taurine intake, you can include toppings like dark-meat poultry, organ meats, eggs, or cooked fish.
Besides poultry, peas and tallow, this food also has carbohydrate sources like tapioca, potato and sweet potato to make up the rest of the food. Other ingredients include goodies like coconut oil, alfalfa and blueberries. I really love that there are no added chemicals, cereals, salt and sugar, items I tend to keep an eye out for when dog food shopping for my pups.
Of course, this food has its shortcomings (like a high percentage of peas), but our research team like its overall composition. Were giving Aldi Natural Elements 3 out of 5 in this category.
Protein content 3.5/5
As weve mentioned above, poultry meal is the first ingredient in all recipes (including salmon and chicken flavour). We appreciate that Aldi has gone slightly above the minimum protein percentage recommended by the AAFCO, so this food features a respectable 28% crude protein percentage. Of course, its safe to assume part of this protein percentage comes from peas.
Poultry meal is a nice first ingredient. According to the AAFCO, poultry meal is the rendered, cooked down of a combination of clean flesh and skin with bone excluding feathers, heads, feet and entrails [1]. While it would be nice to have a second animal protein source, at this price point we cannot ask for more. Poultry meal adds healthy protein to your dogs diet, and its easy to supplement with extras like chicken liver or dark meat as a topper.
Considering the protein sources and the fact that peas represent a good chunk of the total protein, were giving this brand 3.5 out of 5 in this category.
Additives 3/5
We like the little extras this brand has on top of the bulk of the food. Aldi has added interesting ingredients, so weve broken them up down below:
- Beet pulp, chicory root, yucca extract and pumpkin: All these are fibre-rich extras to keep your dogs gut healthy. Our panel of experts note that fibre is just another form of saying prebiotics, the main food source of healthy gut bacteria. Fibre will also help with digestion, so its a useful addition to avoid constipation.
- Salmon oil, coconut oil and vegetable oil: Salmon oil is rich in Omega-6 and Omega-3, essential amino acids that boost your dogs long-term health. Coconut oil is also a so-called healthy fat and can ensure your pup has healthy skin. However, were doubtful about the vegetable oil. Is this a mix of vegetables? Is it palm oil? We dont know, and the exact composition can change from batch to batch.
- Alfalfa, blueberries, cranberries, kelp meal and others: Although these sound enticing, they are probably a very minimal percentage of the overall composition of this food. Nevertheless, I thought it nice to have extra fruits and veggies to round up the micronutrients in the food and add some flavour to the kibble.
Overall, this is a generally good ingredient list with nice extras to round up your dogs diet. Our independent experts had serious doubts about the inclusion of vegetable oil, which is very likely palm oil. Because of this issue, were taking off 2 stars.
Variety 2/5
For a supermarket food, Aldi Natural Elements has a very limited range. All their recipes are targeted at adults, although the packaging mentions it can also be fed to seniors and puppies.
As of the writing of this review, there are two grain-free kibble recipes (chicken, salmon), a wet casserole recipe and two treat options. Both the dry and wet food are grain-free, but the treats are not.
All recipes (including the salmon one) have poultry by-products, so there are no true single-protein options from this brand. I wasn't happy to note that Natural Elements doesnt offer a smaller kibble size, so small and toy pups like mine might have a hard time chewing at mealtimes.
Due to its shortcomings (no senior option, no small dog line), our team is taking off 3 stars.
Price 5/5
Aldi is known for its reasonably priced groceries, so its not a big surprise their dog food range is equally affordable. In general, a small bag will be significantly cheaper than most other brands available in Australia, including other supermarket dog food brands! Larger bags are also relatively inexpensive but still an investment, of course.
Overall, Natural Elements dog food is inexpensive enough to fit households with very large pups or those with multiple dogs. In general, the price is one of the best things about this brand, so our panel is giving it 5 out of 5 in this category.
Aldi Julius Dog Food Review
Have you ever heard of Aldis Julius dog food? This was the first iteration of Aldis dog food home brand. According to Aldis site, the ingredients in Julius dog food are:
Chicken recipe: Meat and Meat By-Products (from Chicken and Beef), Wholegrain Cereals (Wheat and/or Sorghum), Wheat Bran, Vegetable Protein, Tallow, Whole Linseeds and/or Linseed Oil, Beet Pulp, Salt, Prebiotic, Mixed Tocopherols (Vitamin E), Rosemary Plant Extract, Vitamins (A, D, E, K, B1, B2, B6, B12, Niacin, Folic Acid, Biotin, Choline, Pantothenic Acid), Minerals (Iron, Zinc, Copper, Manganese, Selenium, Iodine, Cobalt), Lutein, Garlic, Kelp.
Overall, this ingredient list looks pretty bad. For starters, the first ingredient is a vague meat and meat by-products, apparently from chicken and beef. This includes all parts of the animal except from hooves, horns or manure [1]. The second and third ingredients? Wheat and wheat.
Yes, with their Julius range Aldi used ingredient splitting. Since ingredients have to be named in the percentage they represent within the food, splitting an ingredient (here, as the full cereal and as the bran) allows companies to place it on the second and third position on the ingredient list. The food wouldnt sound so appealing if the first ingredient was wheat, right?
Then we have vegetable protein, a sign that the meat in the first ingredient isnt enough to fulfill the protein requirements in dog food. Our panel of experts also believes that it is also suspicious that no specific vegetable is named. Is this pea protein or plain wheat gluten? Well never know.
The rest of the ingredient list is nice enough, except for the addition of garlic. As weve covered before, garlic can be highly toxic to dogs so it would be better to avoid it altogether.
Comparing Aldi Julius to the more widely available Aldi Natural Elements dog food, the latter is significantly better. Aldi Natural Elements is a grain-free food unlike Aldi Julius that is based around wheat. If you were to buy one or the other, Natural Elements is the better option between the two.
Are Aldi Julius dog food and Aldi Natural Elements dog food the same?
No. Even though they have the same parent company, these two foods have completely different recipes and are in fact different brands.
The Aldi Julius food brand has a wheat-based recipe, while their Natural Elements line does not include wheat in the ingredient list and has a more balanced recipe.
Overall, our independent experts believe that Aldi Natural Elements dog food is a significantly better option than Aldi Julius.
Do not buy if
This brand can be a nice addition to your rotation, but our researchers say you might look elsewhere if you:
- Need a single-protein food: Natural Elements dog food has a salmon recipe, but it isnt a single-protein kibble since it also has poultry tallow. This shouldnt be an issue for most dogs, but some pups are sensitive to common proteins like chicken. If thats your case, skip this brand.
- Are looking for raw food: This brand only offers kibble and wet food, none of which are raw. Of course, at this price point, the only possible raw food might be homemade!
- Want to avoid peas: As weve said, peas and legumes arent necessarily bad for dogs. Your pup can eat them in moderate quantities. But if youd rather have them in lower proportions, this might not be the food for you.
Final Thoughts
For the low price, every member of our expert panel could agree that Aldi Natural Elements is a very decent mid-range food. Considering many other mid-range options, this brand is fairly good! However, remember our word of caution about the mysterious vegetable oil, which might be palm oil.
Other than that, its not a bad choice if your shop of choice is Aldi.
Want to read more dog food brand reviews? Check out the below:
References
- "Understanding Pet Food". Association of American Feed Control Officials AAFCO. Retrieved May 28, 2023.https://www.aafco.org/consumers/understanding-pet-food/
- "Are Peas Safe for Dogs?". The Simple Food Project. Retrieved May 28, 2023.https://simplefoodproject.com/peas-and-grain-free/
- Kaplan J.L, Stern J.A, Fascetti A.J, Larsen J.A, Skolnik H, Peddle G.D, et al. December 13, 2018. "Taurine deficiency and dilated cardiomyopathy in golden retrievers fed commercial diets." PLoS ONE 13(12): e0209112. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0209112. Retrieved May 28, 2023. https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0209112
